View Single Post
  #1 (permalink)  
Old December 30th, 2005
northernflame northernflame is offline
Novicius
 
Join Date: December 29th, 2005
Posts: 1
northernflame is flying high
Default Why is lime wire so slow for dialup?

Hello. I know this has been asked before. However i did a few control tests.

I wished to see the difference between basic and pro limewire.

Testing with the same isp that has all three, dialup, dsl and cable internet services.

Using the same computer, and a remote computer connected to the net and limewire (pro and basic).
Remember each end of the test was tested with equivalent limewire basic or pro and also mixing versions as well. The test was performed over a 2 week peroid and at varying times of the day.


Here is the setup (limewire):

Limewire basic-->dialup setup-->>1000k file-->>> 56kb -modem->>>>speed: 1 k/s

Limewire basic-->dialup setup-->>1000k file-->>> DSL -connection->>>> speed: 15 k/s

Limewire basic-->dialup setup-->>1000k file-->>> CABLE -connection->>>> speed: 18-20 k/s

---------------------------------------------------------------------

Limewire *PRO*-->dialup setup-->>1000k file-->>> 56kb -modem->>>>speed: 1k/s

Limewire *PRO*-->dialup setup-->>1000k file-->>> DSL -connection->>>>speed: 17k/s

Limewire *PRO*-->dialup setup-->>1000k file-->>> cable -connection->>>>speed: 24k/s.

____________________________________________

What's wrong with this picture? I went out of my way to leave the limewire connection type in dialup (control test) form/configuration to test the theory that limewire purposely slows dialup.

Well in this test along with many others the dialup speed
is and an average of 500% slower than it should be.

There is no measurable difference between Basic and pro
for dialup. There is no real significant improovement for DSL either between pro and basic, at least not for 19$ USD.

When one compares this to other on-line share services that send files to dialup at 5 k/s. It leaves one thinking just what is limewire good for if your limited to a dial up
net connection at limewire speeds slower than a 1200 baud modem.

Thinking about it a commodore 64 is faster (no joke).


Thanks for listening.
Reply With Quote