View Single Post
  #1 (permalink)  
Old March 28th, 2002
Raman Raman is offline
Novicius
 
Join Date: March 28th, 2002
Posts: 4
Raman is flying high
Lightbulb File Naming Convention

Hi guys.
This is a problem I'd like to address concerning file sharing on all of gnutella. I actually started this on the XoloX forum at zeropaid.com, but thought I'd take it here as well in order to give it more publicity.

The problem in question is when you try to download a very big file, I'm especially thinking about movies, and you find it under different names.
For example, the other day I found 3 users sharing a certain file, then 4 users sharing the exact same one, as was proven by the size. But I couldn't download it from all 7 at the same time since the name had been modified for one group. -In this case, "DVD" had been added at the end of the movie's name. Which made XoloX think they were different files.

So I thought of suggesting some form of protocole in file naming, for the purpose of sharing.

What I suggest for the moment, for all of you who happen to see this and think it's a valuable idea, is to keep it simple.
-Since this problem concerns big files, especially movies, I propose to simply name them following their release titles, with no add-ons whatsoever.

For example :
The Lord Of The Rings: The Fellowship Of The Ring
Harry Potter And The Philosopher's Stone
Beauty And The Beast

In order to determine what the original title is, just consult a box office or a local cinema's website. (This is what I did for these examples, using cut and paste.)

The only obvious exception to the "no add-on" rule will have to be when the movie comes as separate files. In this case, I suggest adding "CD1", CD2", and so on.
And since that seems rather standard, I would say it should take this form :
The Lord Of The Rings: The Fellowship Of The Ring - CD1
The Lord Of The Rings: The Fellowship Of The Ring - CD2

i.e. space/bar/space (instead of underscores, although I can't say if the gnutella prgrs make the difference between underscores and bars...).

And for the rest, once again if you see this and think it's a good idea, please try and spread the word by all means available to you.
(And if you have a good reason to think it's a worthless idea, please tell me why so I stop trying to figure out a solution.)

Finally, if you have suggestion concerning other types of large files (programs for example), I'd like to hear them.

Thanx to all
Reply With Quote