So you made an exception for LW in the OSX firewall?
Disable Ultrapeer capabilities. Also try disabling some of the other options suggested here in advanced settings:
If LW 4 Will Not Connect (click on the blue link) data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/54ee5/54ee5a2cbffd8b1210a94226e519fab52f1b476c" alt="Smile"
If necessary, restart LW after making the changes.
What brand & model of router are you using?