Use a different player for playing/previewing the files. And just use WMP to add the songs to your library via using the WMP import/scan tool for new media files.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/54ee5/54ee5a2cbffd8b1210a94226e519fab52f1b476c" alt="Smile"
VLC although it's primarily a video player is excellent at playing all audio types you find on Gnutella network. If VLC cannot play the song file then it's probably a fake file;
VLC - (click on link)